back to NGF | radiation | rat haus | Index | Search
NUCLEAR GUARDIANSHIP FORUM, On The Responsible Care of Radioactive Materials,
Issue # 3, Spring 1994, p. 12.

Medical Waste: Trojan Horse?

"Don't get hooked by medical arguments"

by Wendy Oser

As we increasingly try to take responsibility for all radioactive materials and their effects on future life, the thorny question of radioactive isotopes used in medical diagnosis and treatment arises. What dangers do these uses pose for present and future generations? Do their benefits outweigh the risks?

Many corollary questions arise for the public and for medical professionals: Will on-site medical storage in hospitals endanger surrounding neighborhoods? Are "low-level" radioactive dumps (such as the shallow land burial proposed for Ward Valley, California) a necessity, if medical treatment with radiation is to continue? Would the cessation of military and nuclear power production deprive us of life-saving radionuclides?

In Radioactive Waste: The Medical Factor, Minard Hamilton thoroughly examines the production, use and management of radionuclides commonly used in medicine. Her report should stimulate informed discussion on the "low-level" radioactive waste problem among the medical community, public interest groups, government officials, and the utilities and corporations dealing with the waste -- and, hopefully, additional research.

Some of the valuable information revealed in this report:

Physicians and research scientists who honor their commitment to the health of present and future generations should join the debate on radioactive waste.

The report shows that the medical community can eliminate its "need" for radioactive waste burial through the development of non-radioactive alternatives, greater reliance on short-term on-site storage, and electrically generated, waste-free radiation therapy.

There is a terrible irony in the deceptive argument that current medical uses of radioactive materials justify "low-level" waste burial, because this very practice will threaten the health of generations to come. Rather than allowing this argument to go unchallenged, physicians and research scientists who honor their commitment to the health of present and future generations can become informed and join the debate on the whole problem of radioactive waste.

Radioactive Waste: The Medical Factor, by Minard Hamilton, is available from Nuclear Information and Resources Service for $5, 1424 16th Street NW, #404, Washington, DC 20036 USA. tel: 202/328-0002

Minard Hamilton is a Research Associate of Radioactive Waste Management Associates, a consulting firm based in New York City. She has been researching, writing and studying about nuclear waste since 1978, was the co-founder and director of the Radioactive Waste Campaign, co-author of Deadly Defense, a report on radioactive contamination at U.S. Department of Energy nuclear weapons factories, and author of Low-Level Waste Facilities in the U.S. and Canada.

Wendy Oser is a grandmother, a downwinder, and editor of the Nuclear Guardianship Forum.

back to NGF | radiation | rat haus | Index | Search